Strengthening Penta-helix Collaboration in Supporting Indonesian Meat Self-Sufficiency
Strengthening Penta-helix Collaboration in Supporting Indonesian Meat Self-Sufficiency

Strengthening Penta-helix Collaboration in Supporting Indonesian Meat Self-Sufficiency

Authors: Cornelius Tian Andi Sucahyo, Yatim Ardika Yanti, Jovania Cindo Putri J., Fatimah Azzahra

Reviewers : Farid Al-Firdaus, Nadia Faradiba, Muhammad Prayogane

Indonesia’s Vision 2045

Sustainable economic development is one of four pillars in Indonesia’s vision, Indonesia Emas 2045, focused on food security. Providing food is one of the citizens’ basic needs that the country must guarantee. Of all kinds of food, beef is an animal protein source in great demand in Indonesia.

Data from the Ministry of Agriculture showed that beef supply in Indonesia reached 473.878 tons while the demand reached 722.527 tons, making it a deficit of about 34% for 2022. Thus, Indonesia is currently highly dependent on imports to occupy the demand for beef. Solving this problem by conducting the meat self-sufficiency program will contribute to sustainable economic development as the second pillar in Indonesia’s Vision 2045.

Food Security and Meat Self-Sufficiency

The Food and Agriculture Organization suggests that food security is the product of food availability, food access, stability of supplies, and biological utilization. While meat self-sufficiency means that at least 90% of beef needs are met from domestic production, the remaining 10% is fulfilled from imports, including those from feeder cattle imports (Ditjennak, 2010).

To achieve food security and meat self-sufficiency, the government has included food security in the 2022-2024 National Development Agenda by prioritizing programs to increase availability, access, and quality of food consumption through increasing domestic productivity and substituting activities that depend on other countries. Therefore, synergism from the government, the involvement of academics in creating technology and innovation, and the role of the private sector and the community must be integrated to accelerate the achievement of national meat self-sufficiency.

Penta-helix Strategies

To achieve meat self-sufficiency in 2045, the Indonesian government must solve numerous things. The government could obtain this substantial program using a collaborative and cooperative approach with penta-helix strategies.

1.     Government Program Refocusing

The failure of meat self-sufficiency in Indonesia allegedly occurred because too many government programs from the Ministry of Agriculture were launched. To meet the demand for domestic beef, the government has several programs that are expected to help meat self-sufficiency targets. Some programs launched are the development of organic fertilizer and biogas, breeding management, and empowerment to improve the quality of slaughterhouses (Fitri dan Handayani, 2020). Those programs must be reviewed based on the government programs’ priority scale, significantly affecting meat self-sufficiency.

To support the optimization of this program, the Ministry of Agriculture can refocus on a program with the highest priority, namely breeding which can produce good quality. It has become one of the most essential pillars due to livestock maintenance because it is a cultivation activity that produces livestock for multi-purpose reasons (Amam dan Harsita, 2019). In this case, the breeding program should be prioritized because it provides continuity of long-term benefits compared to other programs. By that, the number of imported beef is expected to decrease gradually and the provision of meat from domestic cattle will also be fulfilled sooner.

2.  Business Involvement

Related to the government’s efforts in maintaining food availability by increasing domestic production, the government can collaborate with the commercial sector by communicating their programs to invest in beef cattle breeding and also can provide facilitation schemes in it, such as regular counseling on improving cattle quality, expanding the market, and assisting access to funding.

The commercial sector is an enabler, implying that the business becomes the upstream-to-downstream link in the supply chain. In this role, the business provides livestock installations, operations, and distribution to end consumers. 

3.     Community collaboration

Smallholder farmers are the most vulnerable in beef cattle production (Agus, A. and Widi, T.S., 2018). They commonly conventionally raise their farm, such as keeping their livestock as a livelihood asset for saving and investment. Farmers should be encouraged to change their conventional paradigm into a commercial. Meanwhile, the government should form a partnership with smallholder farmers and prepare a valuable offer as an incentive for them, such as providing free artificial insemination to farmers in empowering them to contribute to the nation’s beef supplies. Artificial insemination is a fertility treatment with many benefits, such as increasing livestock reproductive efficiency and disseminating high-quality breeds (Hidayat A, 2020). Since artificial insemination requires well-trained trainers and special equipment to perform operations (Rauthan et al., 2022), gaining a free treatment of it will be a satisfying treat for the cattle and farmer. Thus, this mutually beneficial collaboration needs to be carried out to foster community interest in being involved in the national meat supply chain.

4. Media Participation & Education

As a disseminating tool, the media must raise awareness about farming among kids, fresh graduates, and adults. Kids can start to be educated about cattle and farming in early education, such as gaining real experience by visiting a farming field. Media can also provide children with farming content to raise their interest. Besides, many fresh graduates avoid becoming farmers or building a livestock business and choose formal jobs or work in a corporation, so they need to understand that the cattle business is promising. Lastly, the media can disseminate government programs that support cattle farming so adults can realize the development opportunities and have another perspective regarding their careers.

5.     Research and Development Plan

Conducting research and development is one of the ways to provide information that can be useful in many aspects, including policymaking. It can enlighten a policymaker and put workable policy options in their hands (James, L., Garrett, J. and Islam, Y., 2009). Research can be carried out to obtain new methods in cattle farming or strengthen the previous study. Thus, academics need to take a role in developing an excellent innovation and provide advice on developing cattle farming in Indonesia. A National Research and Innovation Agency researcher stated that specific strategies and policies are recommended for achieving meat self-sufficiency, among others, increasing population and high-quality breeds through breeding and genetic improvement.

Therefore, a specific budget must be allocated to strengthen research in this field. The allocation of research funds can be taken from budget optimization as the result of program refocusing so that the study can be more optimal.

6.     Benchmarking

Benchmarking is required to obtain best practices for strengthening cattle farming in Indonesia. Government can do benchmarking in some countries that already have best practices in cattle farming, such as Australia, the USA, New Zealand, and Japan, so that farmers will be educated and the quality of the meat itself will be increased. Concerned with the benchmarking result, these are best practices that can be applied with some adjustments based on Indonesian conditions:

a. Most cattle from those countries are raised exclusively on pastures. It is aligned with the research from the Riddet Institute led by Dr. Lovedeep Kaur and Dr. Mike Boland, which stated that meat quality depends on how the animal is raised.

b. Those countries set their standards for meat quality assurance and animal welfare in agriculture, along with programs on animal care and providing farmers with educational resources.

c. Those countries select the cattle’s breed based on gene quality.

Conclusion

The local meat supply in Indonesia should meet the consumption needs of the whole community. Indonesia has great potential to be meat self-sufficient, but the government must take strategic measures to achieve it by strengthening the penta-helix collaboration. Several strategies can be implemented, including government program refocusing, supporting research, benchmarking, and cooperation with multiple elements such as the business, the community, media, and academia. However, these interrelated strategies must be implemented in an integrated and sustainable way. Thus, Indonesia can achieve meat self-sufficiency following Indonesia’s Vision 2045.

REFERENCES

James, L., Garrett, J., & Islam, Y. (2009). Policy Research And The Policy-Process: Do The Twain Ever Meet. Gatekeeper Series No. SA74.

Gibson, M. Food Security—A Commentary: What Is It and Why Is It So Complicated? Foods 2012, 1, 18-27. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods1010018

Agus, A., & Widi, T. S. (2018). Current situation and prospect of beef cattle production in Indonesia: a brief review. Asian Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences, 41.

Amam, A., & Harsita, P. A. (2019). Tiga pilar usaha ternak: breeding, feeding, and management. Jurnal Sain Peternakan Indonesia, 14(4), 431-439.

Kementerian PPN/Bappenas. (2019). Ringkasan Eksekutif Visi Indonesia 2045. Jakarta: Kementerian PPN/Bappenas.

Fitri, A., & Handayani, S. (2020). Kajian Kebijakan Daging Sapi di Indonesia untuk Mendukung Swasembada Daging Sapi. DwijenAGRO, 10(1), 27-39.

Indonesian Institute of Sciences. (2020, October 7). Tujuh Saran Kebijakan Wujudkan Swasembada Daging Nasional. http://lipi.go.id/berita/single/Tujuh-Saran-Kebijakan-Wujudkan-Swasembada-Daging-Nasional/22175

University of New Zealand. (2021, October 6). New study highlights differences in New Zealand beef. https://www.massey.ac.nz/about/news/new-study-highlights-differences-in-new-zealand-beef/

Pusat Data dan Sistem Informasi Pertanian. (2022). Outlook Komoditas Daging Sapi dan Kerbau. Jakarta: Kementerian Pertanian.

https://finance.detik.com/berita-ekonomi-bisnis/d-5512494/stok-sapi-ri-melimpah-tapi-kenapa-masih-saja-impor

https://www.ekon.go.id/publikasi/detail/3496/strategi-menjaga-ketahanan-pangan-nasional-dalam-agenda-pembangunan-nasional

https://www.aseanbriefing.com/news/australias-beef-exports-to-indonesia-highlights-wider-potential-for-halal-products/

https://www.agriculture.gov.au/agriculture-land/farm-food-drought/meat-wool-dairy/red-meat-livestock/facts

https://www.goodmeat.com.au/animal-health-welfare/red-meat-and-on-farm-practices/

https://truorganicbeef.com/blogs/beef-wiki/australian-beef-vs-u-s-beef-15-differences

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

https://motor138.com/ slot777 https://holdinoutforahero.org/ https://makhairulummah.sch.id/ slot gacor 2024 https://kitab.chair-annizomiyah.ponpes.id/ https://spada.chair-annizomiyah.ponpes.id/ https://blogs.chair-annizomiyah.ponpes.id/ https://pemdesrejoagung.web.id/ https://pustaka.kbjatim.id/ https://tk.umuka.ac.id/ gacor4d TOTO MACAU MPO slot mahjong slot777 slot thailand slot 777 slot88 slot thailand slot zeus slot maxwin slot mpo sv388 sbobet slot 2025 data macau ladangtoto mpo online slot thailand slot zeus gacor4d slot777 sv388 sbobet88 baccarat online scatter hitam slot thailand slot zeus slot mpo gacor4d slot mahjong slot88 sv388 baccarat online live draw hk slot777 data macau toto 4d zeus slot sultan toto live casino mpo slot togel hk sv388 slot thailand mpo slot toto slot sv388 togel hk toto macau togel sgp mpo slot sv388 togel macau mpo slot slot thailand demo slot toto slot sbobet88 scatter hitam ladangtoto2 slot maxwin slot gacor 2025 slot88 slot gacor mpo slot sv388 slot88 togel hk toto macau toto slot mpo slot slot pulsa slot777 slot gacor pay4d motor138 slot gacor 2025 slot resmi slot server thailand slot gacor 4d zeus slot baccarat online mahjong ways 2 SBOBET88 mpo slot slot maxwin slot thailand mpo gacor4d slot77 zeus slot akun pro thailand slot depo 10k mpo slot baccarat online slot 2025 slot gacor 4d slot zeus slot thailand data macau 4d slot gacor 2025 slot mpo slot thailand sv388 gacor4d scatter hitam data hk 2025 slot gacor 4d slot mpo toto macau 4d togel hk zeus slot slot resmi data macau slot thailand gacor slot gacor 2025 mpo online slot77 slot thailand gacor menangbet88 sv388 mpo slot togel sgp mpo slot slot pulsa slot zeus demo slot slot zeus toto slot https://www.awrestaurants.co.id/ https://hitmakerstudios.com/ https://buffalobehavioralmedicine.org/ https://tk.umuka.ac.id/umum/ https://www.trgindia.org/ slot mahjong slot maxwin mpo slot thailand zeus slot slot thailand gacor4d slot88 sv388 slot zeus mahjong ways gacor4d zeus slot Motor138 sv388 slot mpo data macau 4d slot88 slot thailand gacor4d slot thailand slot gacor 777 mahjong ways 2 gacor4d sv388 toto slot togel hk slot77 pulsa slot thailand mpo slot online sv388 mpo slot toto slot gacor togel hongkong slot gacor toto slot slot88 slot maxwin sbobet88 demo slot data sgp toto slot slot88 slot maxwin sbobet88 demo slot gacor data sgp hari ini Motor138 toto slot mpo slot togel hk Slot Gacor https://dlh.bangkatengahkab.go.id/ https://www.dinasperikanan.bangkatengahkab.go.id/ Motor138 slot 77 togel sgp mpo toto macau mahjong wins 3 slot77 mpo gacor4d slot thailand ladangtoto slot88 gacor4d scatter hitam slot77 slot zeus sv388 slot thailand slot maxwin slot toto slot mahjong sv388 slot gacor 2025 slot thailand zeus slot rtp slot live draw macau sbobet88 ladangtoto wangi787 slot maxwin slot mpo gacor4d slot gacor https://kianprima.kedirikota.go.id/ togel sgp Motor138 slot zeus togel hk sv388 slot thailand gacor4d wangi787 scatter hitam zeus slot online slot server thailand slot thailand mpo slot zeus gacor4d mahjong ways 2 casino online data macau mpo slot sv388 sv388 toto slot mpo slot toto macau togel hk togel sgp mpo slot togel sdy toto macau toto slot slot88 mpo togel sgp mpo togel hk mahjong ways 2 slot mahjong gacor4d slot mpo wangi787 sv388 slot zeus data macau ws168 mahjong ways 2 mpo gacor slot maxwin slot thailand casino online mahjong ways 2 http://www.diskominfosta.bangkatengahkab.go.id/laporan/ togel sgp togel sdy wangi787 https://pmc.org.pk/assets/ toto macau 4d wangi787 slot thailand mahjong ways 2 http://e-bphtb.pandeglangkab.go.id/file/ wangi787 slot thailand slot mpo slot thailand slot thailand mpo toto slot mpo sv388 slot88 MPO togel sgp togel sdy https://pmb.sttmigas.ac.id/setting/ Motor138 Motor138 motor138 toto macau toto macau motor138 mpo slot777 togel online slot gacor sbobe88 slot demo akun jp toto slot slot 88 sv388 togel sdy slot demo togel sgp toto macau slot77 slot demo gacor4d slot pulsa slot mahjong mpo togel hk togel sgp slot77 toto slot mpo demo slot sv388 togel sdy togel hk togel sgp GACOR4D Motor138 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 gacor4d slot thailand slot gacor wangi787 sv388 slot88 slot thailand mpo slot777 togel sdy togel sgp sv388 slot pulsa motor138 togel sdy mpo motor138 slot gacor sv388 wangi787 wangi787 slot thailand wangi787 baccarat online slot thailand slot zeus baccarat online slot maxwin wangi787 wangi787 slot mpo slot thailand data macau mahjong ways 2 data sgp live draw hk baccarat online sbobet88 motor138 mpo online slot pulsa demo slot https://simpatda.kedirikab.go.id/pompom/ toto slot mpo wangi787 https://linkr.bio/Wangi787/ wangi787 https://www.facebook.com/groups/wangi787/ https://t.me/wangi787officialasli slot77 mpo slot88 slot777 scatter hitam motor138 wangi787 zeus slot slot thailand wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 slot mpo wangi787 slot mpo slot zeus mahjong ways 2 gacor4d slot zeus wangi787 wangi787 togel sdy toto slot mpo togel sgp slot77 togel sdy togel sgp togel hk mpo online mpo sv388 toto macau slot demo motor138 sbobet88 motor138 mpo wangi787 wangi787 scatter hitam paito hk slot gacor 2025 sv388 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 slot mpo ladangtoto slot mahjong motor138 togel sdy toto macau mpo motor138 demo slot sv388 mpo slot online zeus slot sv388 wangi787 gacor4d zeus slot wangi787 slot 2025 wangi787 wangi787 motor138 mpo sv388 togel hk togel sgp togel sdy slot demo slot mahjong sv388 sbobet88 toto slot toto macau slot malaysia slot malaysia mpo online slot malaysia sv388 togel sgp wangi787 zeus slot data macau wangi787 wangi787 mahjong ways sv388 wangi787 slot mpo wangi787 mahjong slot wangi787 wangi787 slot thailand zeus slot demo slot toto slot sv388 togel sgp slot88 togel hk togel sgp togel sdy slot malaysia motor138 toto slot sv388 slot thailand motor138 mahjong ways sv388 slot88 toto macau togel hk wangi787 wangi787 slot zeus slot mpo wangi787 wangi787 slot gacor wangi787 mahjong ways 2 sabung ayam online slot777 slot demo sv388 motor138 sv388 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 slot mpo slot zeus sv388 https://minify.biz/wangi https://minify.biz/wangi787 baccarat online mpo slot88 motor138 togel hk togel sdy togel sgp sv388 motor138 slot88 slot demo gacor4d toto slot slot777 toto macau ladangtoto slot gacor mpo sv388 slot77 slot malaysia mpo slot kamboja motor138 sbobet88 slot thailand slot zeus gacor4d slot777 sv388 slot gacor 2025 slot qris sbobet88 motor138 motor138 slot pulsa toto slot slot zeus mpo toto macau slot77 slot88 sv388 motor138 slot demo mpo sv388 motor138 sv388 motor138 toto slot slot77 slot demo slot gacor slot online slot maxwin motor138 slot88 slot77 slot pulsa toto macau togel sdy togel sgp motor138 slot88 slot777 mpo slot777 baccarat online slot88 mpo slot wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 gacor4d slot 2025 mpo sv388 togel sgp togel sdy slot88 sv388 mpo togel sgp togel sdy togel hk toto macau slot malaysia sv388 slot88 wangi787 wangi787 wangi787 slot gacor 2025 slot demo mpo sv388 togel sgp slot gacor togel sdy toto macau togel hk mpo lk21 sv388 slot maxwin slot777 slot maxwin wangi787 sv388 slot demo slot88 togel sgp slot maxwin wangi787 slot zeus wangi787 mahjong ways 2 ladangtoto slot gacor 2025 lk21 slot88 slot777 toto slot slot88 slot777 slot88